Welcome Informed Criticism of Your Work


When you come to 'know' something, there is a temptation to stop thinking about it. You put it in a box as 'known' and are happy to argue with anyone who disagrees.

This is both a good and a bad thing.

It is good to hold firm to your beliefs, to be true to yourself, to stand your ground over knowledge or a belief that is fundamental to your character and values.

That said, holding stubbornly to your point of view, allowing no space for doubt, can be limiting. Oliver Cromwell is reported to have said to Charles I, on the eve of the king's execution, "I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, consider is possible that you may be wrong." Or words to that effect. Charles I was clearly in no mood to change his mind, and the outcome was not pleasant for him.

Holding true to what you 'know' in terms of copywriting is clearly small potatoes when compared to the decision Charles I faced.

However, we are still faced with the same questions. Should we always hold fast to what we know about our craft? Or should we allow for the possibility that there are better ways to write, different approaches to take, alternative words to consider?

No and yes. No, we shouldn't back down every time a client or colleague questions our work. Yes, we should consider the possibility that what we knew from last year may not be the best choice this year.

So at least, when you have written some copy, seek out a contrarian view. Find someone who's opinion you respect. Ask them to read your copy carefully and criticize it in any way they want. And then consider their views carefully.

Discard criticism that you truly feel is not on target. But also, leave yourself open to the opportunity to grow as a writer, expand your knowledge and skills, and find new, better ways to extend your craft.

Nick Usborne is a copywriter, author, speaker and advocat of good writing. You can access all his archived newsletter articles on copywriting and writing for the web at his Excess Voice site. You'll find more articles and resources on how to make money as a freelance writer at his Freelance Writing Success site.







Related News



Copywriting for Direct Mail - Part 3: Five Motivators - Web Host Industry Review

Copywriting for Direct Mail - Part 3: Five Motivators
Web Host Industry Review -Dec 16, 2008
The offer is the theme of your communication. Begin with it. Restate it. Denote its key benefits. The actual product or service is largely incidental to ...

North Carolina Freelance Content Copywriter Jason Pedley Announces ... - dBusinessNews Triangle (press release)

North Carolina Freelance Content Copywriter Jason Pedley Announces ...
dBusinessNews Triangle (press release), NC -3 hours ago
The new site features an expanded online copywriter portfolio as well as new copywriter services pages that give descriptions of the copywriting and ...

“How to Explode Your Website’s Marketing Potential With A Few Easy ... - NewsReleaseWire.com (press release)

“How to Explode Your Website’s Marketing Potential With A Few Easy ...
NewsReleaseWire.com (press release) -22 hours ago
Copywriting – the content of your website -- will pull traffic to your website and add clients to your practice, even with a simple design. ...


10 ADVERTISING WORDS TO AVOID IN 2009 - Gather.com

10 ADVERTISING WORDS TO AVOID IN 2009
Gather.com, MA -Dec 31, 2008
In 2009, perhaps more than ever, the words you use in your copywriting can determine whether you make a sale or lose a customer. Here are 10 words to avoid ...

eWriting Café Announces the Launch of New Website - PR.com (press release)

eWriting Café Announces the Launch of New Website
PR.com (press release), NY -14 hours ago
“As a contract copywriter, eWriting Café offers copywriting services for businesses in need of clear, professional marketing copy that’s on time, ...

Weekly Web Tip #7 - Stop Hemorrhaging Leads & Sales - Furniture World Magazine (press release)

Weekly Web Tip #7 - Stop Hemorrhaging Leads & Sales
Furniture World Magazine (press release) -Jan 5, 2009
That’s not the case with the product of commercial writing known as “copywriting.” Most everyone can write today; it only takes a pen and paper. ...

The Ultimate Web Copywriting Secret - PWO

The Ultimate Web Copywriting Secret
PWO, France -Dec 28, 2008
But just like the Rolex, each component of web copywriting has finer details and nuances which are hard to explain in detail in a short article. ...

4 Fatal Mistakes Most Internet Marketers Made In Copywriting Part I - PWO

4 Fatal Mistakes Most Internet Marketers Made In Copywriting Part I
PWO, France -Dec 18, 2008
It is the culture of the Chinese to avoid any number that have the digit '4' in them.Here is '4' Fatal Mistakes that most internet marketers made when ...

Take Steps to Recession Proof Your Small Business - MSNBC

Take Steps to Recession Proof Your Small Business
MSNBC -Jan 6, 2009
... and checks; promotional apparel including hats and T-shirts; and marketing services such as copywriting, Websites, design and postcard mailing. ...

Zuula Consulting is the New Face of Communication - PR Newswire (press release)

Zuula Consulting is the New Face of Communication
PR Newswire (press release), NY -Jan 5, 2009
From creating copy for websites and brochures to ghostwriting books and editing newsletters, this boutique copywriting firm helps businesses and ...
Zuula Consulting is the New Face of CommunicationInternational Business Times
all 6 news articles